Suri has just finished her freshman year of Carnegie Mellon University. The budding star was makeup free with her dark hair worn back as she had on a tank top and baggy blue denim jeans.

Tom Cruise has been a movie star for 40 years and he's racked up quite the list of romantic credits—some real, so many rumored—since his divorce from third wife Katie Holmes in 2012.

It all seemed so buttoned up, yet the show’s original creator, Kevin Williamson, says there were conversations about going ...