NEW YORK — On Tuesday evening in a Brooklyn warehouse lit with a pink cast, the Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show was back.

As the show returned following a years-long hiatus, Alex Consani and Valentina Sampaio made history as the first transgender women to walk for the brand.

Ms. Weinstock, 34, is a beauty editor for System magazine in London and the author of the newly published book “ How to Be a Goth: Notes on Undead Style.” “I don’t know what to wear for Halloween,” ...