According to our panel of experts, a great chocolate ice cream checks several key boxes. Here’s what to look for to ensure every scoop is as delicious as it should be: Simple ingredients ...

Notably, the packaging on Wegmans' and Costco's ice-cream bars advertised desserts with a "chocolate-flavored coating," but the 365 box said its dessert was "dipped in organic chocolate." ...

The Peanuts for Chocolate ice cream was seemingly made for fans of peanut ... so it didn't quite achieve the cookies-and-creme flavor advertised on the box. That wasn't a dealbreaker, though.