Shop Halloween Eye Candy

Ads
$3.97
Wilton Candy Eyeballs For Frosted Treats, Black And White Candy Sprinkles, 0.88 Oz.
Walmart
In store
6
90-day returns
Curbside
$3.97
Wilton Candy Eyeballs For Frosted Treats, Black And White Candy Sprinkles, 0.88 Oz.
Walmart
6
$8.99
Fusion Select 2 Packs Eye Popping Gummies - Sweet Eyeball Candy For Halloween, Birthday, Trick Or Treat, Party Candy - Individually Wrapped Jelly Fill
Walmart
2
$8.99
Fusion Select 2 Packs Eye Popping Gummies - Sweet Eyeball Candy For Halloween, Birthday, Trick Or Treat, Party Candy - Individually Wrapped Jelly Fill
Walmart
2
$21.67
Gummy Eyeballs 2 Pound Package 100 Pieces Of Candy | Halloween Candies | Bulk Gummi | Bloodshot Eyeball
Walmart
Free shipping
$21.67
Gummy Eyeballs 2 Pound Package 100 Pieces Of Candy | Halloween Candies | Bulk Gummi | Bloodshot Eyeball
Walmart
Free shipping
$7.99
Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Eyes Candy Cookie Decorations 1/4" 120 Count
Walmart
2
30-day returns
$7.99
Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Eyes Candy Cookie Decorations 1/4" 120 Count
Walmart
2
$9.49
Wilton® Assorted Candy Eyeballs Tacklebox 2.75 Oz
Kroger
In store
26
Curbside
$9.49
Wilton® Assorted Candy Eyeballs Tacklebox 2.75 Oz
Kroger
26
$8.52
Halloween Scary Bloodshot Eyeballs Edible Sugar Decorations - 12 Count - 42406 - This Item Is Packaged Between Food Safe Foam And Is Heat Sealed In A
Walmart
Free shipping
30-day returns
$8.52
Halloween Scary Bloodshot Eyeballs Edible Sugar Decorations - 12 Count - 42406 - This Item Is Packaged Between Food Safe Foam And Is Heat Sealed In A
Walmart
30-day returns
$4.99
Wilton Candy Eyeballs 1.28 Oz
Kroger
In store
4K+
Curbside
$4.99
Wilton Candy Eyeballs 1.28 Oz
Kroger
4K+
$12.62
Candy Decorations .88Oz-Christmas Small Eyeballs
Walmart
5
Free shipping
30-day returns
$12.62
Candy Decorations .88Oz-Christmas Small Eyeballs
Walmart
5
$7.99
Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 7/16" 84 Count
Walmart
30-day returns
$7.99
Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 7/16" 84 Count
Walmart
30-day returns
$29.74
$40.24
Eyeball Orbs Halloween Decorations, Home Decor, Halloween, 9 Pieces
Walmart
2
Free shipping
26% off
$29.74
$40.24
Eyeball Orbs Halloween Decorations, Home Decor, Halloween, 9 Pieces
Walmart
2
$5.43
$6.79
Wilton 2.75 Oz Edible Black & White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles
Blain's Farm & Fleet
26
20% off
$5.43
$6.79
Wilton 2.75 Oz Edible Black & White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles
Blain's Farm & Fleet
26
$2.99
$5.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Orange & Black Peanut Butter Kisses
Blain's Farm & Fleet
50% off
$2.99
$5.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Orange & Black Peanut Butter Kisses
Blain's Farm & Fleet
$39.95
$79.95
Halloween Eyeball Chocolate Truffle Cake Pops - 12 Pops - Gourmet Food Shipped
Mackenzie LTD
$10 Off*
50% off
$39.95
$79.95
Halloween Eyeball Chocolate Truffle Cake Pops - 12 Pops - Gourmet Food Shipped
Mackenzie LTD
$10 Off*
$19.02
Betty Crocker Candy Shop, Eyeballs (Pack Of 2)
Walmart
$19.02
Betty Crocker Candy Shop, Eyeballs (Pack Of 2)
Walmart
$8.48
Wilton Candy Eyeballs, Small
Walmart
94
Free shipping
$8.48
Wilton Candy Eyeballs, Small
Walmart
94
$2.99
$5.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Peanut Butter Chocolate Eyeballs
Blain's Farm & Fleet
50% off
$2.99
$5.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Peanut Butter Chocolate Eyeballs
Blain's Farm & Fleet
$6.99
40 Pc Gummy Eyeballs Candy
Oriental Trading Company
$6.99
40 Pc Gummy Eyeballs Candy
Oriental Trading Company
$1.49
$2.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 8 Oz Gummi Eyeballs
Blain's Farm & Fleet
50% off
$1.49
$2.99
Blain's Farm & Fleet 8 Oz Gummi Eyeballs
Blain's Farm & Fleet
$11.88
Gummy Eyeball Candies, Halloween Party Candy, Pack Of 2, 1.97 Ounces Per Pack
Walmart
$11.88
Gummy Eyeball Candies, Halloween Party Candy, Pack Of 2, 1.97 Ounces Per Pack
Walmart
$13.63
Glow In The Dark Halloween Sunnies, Personalized Sunglasses For Kids, Fall Novelty Eye Wear, Candy Free Trick Or Treat, Class Party Favors
Etsy
$13.63
Glow In The Dark Halloween Sunnies, Personalized Sunglasses For Kids, Fall Novelty Eye Wear, Candy Free Trick Or Treat, Class Party Favors
Etsy
$8.20
Candyfetti Marshmallow Eyeballs, 2.54Oz, 12Ct
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$8.20
Candyfetti Marshmallow Eyeballs, 2.54Oz, 12Ct
Faire
60-day returns
$18.81
Wilton Mini Candy Eyeballs
Walmart
163
Free shipping
$18.81
Wilton Mini Candy Eyeballs
Walmart
163
$10.99
Wilton Large Edible Black And White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles, 1 Oz.
Walmart
15
$10.99
Wilton Large Edible Black And White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles, 1 Oz.
Walmart
15
$8.55
Wilton Red Vein Candy Eyeballs, Edible Candies For Icing Decorating, 1 Oz., 0.72 in. Diameter
Walmart
$8.55
Wilton Red Vein Candy Eyeballs, Edible Candies For Icing Decorating, 1 Oz., 0.72 in. Diameter
Walmart
$29.08
$34.20
(4 Pack) Wilton Red Vein Candy Eyeballs, Edible Candies For Icing Decorating, 1 Oz., 0.72 in. Diameter
Walmart
2
14% off
$29.08
$34.20
(4 Pack) Wilton Red Vein Candy Eyeballs, Edible Candies For Icing Decorating, 1 Oz., 0.72 in. Diameter
Walmart
2
$7.99
Edible Halloween Yellow Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 1/4" 120 Count
Walmart
30-day returns
$7.99
Edible Halloween Yellow Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 1/4" 120 Count
Walmart
30-day returns
$24.99
Halloween Candy Eyeballs Gummies Jam Filled (38 Ounce Box - 60 Count)
Walmart
Free shipping
$24.99
Halloween Candy Eyeballs Gummies Jam Filled (38 Ounce Box - 60 Count)
Walmart
Free shipping
$34.99
100 Pcs Chocolate Eyeballs Halloween Candy Party Favor Kisses (1 Lb) - No Assembly Required
Walmart
$34.99
100 Pcs Chocolate Eyeballs Halloween Candy Party Favor Kisses (1 Lb) - No Assembly Required
Walmart
$13.00
$20.99
Eyeball Print Lollipops (1Lb) - Edibles - 46 Pieces
Walmart
30
38% off
$13.00
$20.99
Eyeball Print Lollipops (1Lb) - Edibles - 46 Pieces
Walmart
30
$44.99
Assorted Chocolate Candy Variety Pack - Assorted Bulk Chocolate Mix - Individually Wrapped Party Chocolate Assortment - Chocolate For Every Occasion
Amazon.com
5
Free shipping
$44.99
Assorted Chocolate Candy Variety Pack - Assorted Bulk Chocolate Mix - Individually Wrapped Party Chocolate Assortment - Chocolate For Every Occasion
Amazon.com
5
$20.99
Gummy Eyeballs - Premium Halloween Gummy By Ny Spice - Free Ship
eBay
Free shipping
Used
$20.99
Gummy Eyeballs - Premium Halloween Gummy By Ny Spice - Free Ship
eBay
Free shipping
$3.99
Gummi Eyeballs, Halloween Treats
Etsy
3K+
$3.99
Gummi Eyeballs, Halloween Treats
Etsy
3K+
$34.00
HALLOWEEN Eyeballs Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Rods, Halloween Party Favors, Halloween Pretzels Party Treats, Halloween Gifts For Kids
Etsy
Free shipping
$34.00
HALLOWEEN Eyeballs Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Rods, Halloween Party Favors, Halloween Pretzels Party Treats, Halloween Gifts For Kids
Etsy
Free shipping
$26.00
Halloween Candy | Candy Skewers | Candy Kabobs | Gummy Candy | Body Parts | Gummy Eyeball | Client Gift
Etsy
1K+
$26.00
Halloween Candy | Candy Skewers | Candy Kabobs | Gummy Candy | Body Parts | Gummy Eyeball | Client Gift
Etsy
1K+
$27.00
Eye Ball Lollipops - Halloween Favors - Halloween Party Favor - Human Eye Candy - 9 Lollipops
Etsy
2K+
$27.00
Eye Ball Lollipops - Halloween Favors - Halloween Party Favor - Human Eye Candy - 9 Lollipops
Etsy
2K+
$12.99
Apexy Eyeball Gummy Candy With Fruity Liquid Center Fat Free Perfect For Halloween & Themed Parties, Fun & Delicious 11.42Oz
Walmart
188
$12.99
Apexy Eyeball Gummy Candy With Fruity Liquid Center Fat Free Perfect For Halloween & Themed Parties, Fun & Delicious 11.42Oz
Walmart
188
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Halloween Eye Candy

    Ads
    $3.97
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs For Frosted Treats, Black And White Candy Sprinkles, 0.88 Oz.
    Walmart
    In store
    6
    90-day returns
    Curbside
    $3.97
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs For Frosted Treats, Black And White Candy Sprinkles, 0.88 Oz.
    Walmart
    6
    $8.99
    Fusion Select 2 Packs Eye Popping Gummies - Sweet Eyeball Candy For Halloween, Birthday, Trick Or Treat, Party Candy - Individually Wrapped Jelly Fill
    Walmart
    2
    $8.99
    Fusion Select 2 Packs Eye Popping Gummies - Sweet Eyeball Candy For Halloween, Birthday, Trick Or Treat, Party Candy - Individually Wrapped Jelly Fill
    Walmart
    2
    $21.67
    Gummy Eyeballs 2 Pound Package 100 Pieces Of Candy | Halloween Candies | Bulk Gummi | Bloodshot Eyeball
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $21.67
    Gummy Eyeballs 2 Pound Package 100 Pieces Of Candy | Halloween Candies | Bulk Gummi | Bloodshot Eyeball
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $7.99
    Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Eyes Candy Cookie Decorations 1/4" 120 Count
    Walmart
    2
    30-day returns
    $7.99
    Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Eyes Candy Cookie Decorations 1/4" 120 Count
    Walmart
    2
    $9.49
    Wilton® Assorted Candy Eyeballs Tacklebox 2.75 Oz
    Kroger
    In store
    26
    Curbside
    $9.49
    Wilton® Assorted Candy Eyeballs Tacklebox 2.75 Oz
    Kroger
    26
    $8.52
    Halloween Scary Bloodshot Eyeballs Edible Sugar Decorations - 12 Count - 42406 - This Item Is Packaged Between Food Safe Foam And Is Heat Sealed In A
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    30-day returns
    $8.52
    Halloween Scary Bloodshot Eyeballs Edible Sugar Decorations - 12 Count - 42406 - This Item Is Packaged Between Food Safe Foam And Is Heat Sealed In A
    Walmart
    30-day returns
    $4.99
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs 1.28 Oz
    Kroger
    In store
    4K+
    Curbside
    $4.99
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs 1.28 Oz
    Kroger
    4K+
    $12.62
    Candy Decorations .88Oz-Christmas Small Eyeballs
    Walmart
    5
    Free shipping
    30-day returns
    $12.62
    Candy Decorations .88Oz-Christmas Small Eyeballs
    Walmart
    5
    $7.99
    Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 7/16" 84 Count
    Walmart
    30-day returns
    $7.99
    Edible Halloween Green Candy Eyeballs Icing Royal Eyes Candy Eyes 7/16" 84 Count
    Walmart
    30-day returns
    $29.74
    $40.24
    Eyeball Orbs Halloween Decorations, Home Decor, Halloween, 9 Pieces
    Walmart
    2
    Free shipping
    26% off
    $29.74
    $40.24
    Eyeball Orbs Halloween Decorations, Home Decor, Halloween, 9 Pieces
    Walmart
    2
    $5.43
    $6.79
    Wilton 2.75 Oz Edible Black & White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    26
    20% off
    $5.43
    $6.79
    Wilton 2.75 Oz Edible Black & White Candy Eyeball Sprinkles
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    26
    $2.99
    $5.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Orange & Black Peanut Butter Kisses
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    50% off
    $2.99
    $5.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Orange & Black Peanut Butter Kisses
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    $39.95
    $79.95
    Halloween Eyeball Chocolate Truffle Cake Pops - 12 Pops - Gourmet Food Shipped
    Mackenzie LTD
    $10 Off*
    50% off
    $39.95
    $79.95
    Halloween Eyeball Chocolate Truffle Cake Pops - 12 Pops - Gourmet Food Shipped
    Mackenzie LTD
    $10 Off*
    $19.02
    Betty Crocker Candy Shop, Eyeballs (Pack Of 2)
    Walmart
    $19.02
    Betty Crocker Candy Shop, Eyeballs (Pack Of 2)
    Walmart
    $8.48
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs, Small
    Walmart
    94
    Free shipping
    $8.48
    Wilton Candy Eyeballs, Small
    Walmart
    94
    $2.99
    $5.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Peanut Butter Chocolate Eyeballs
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    50% off
    $2.99
    $5.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 16 Oz Peanut Butter Chocolate Eyeballs
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    $6.99
    40 Pc Gummy Eyeballs Candy
    Oriental Trading Company
    $6.99
    40 Pc Gummy Eyeballs Candy
    Oriental Trading Company
    $1.49
    $2.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 8 Oz Gummi Eyeballs
    Blain's Farm & Fleet
    50% off
    $1.49
    $2.99
    Blain's Farm & Fleet 8 Oz Gummi Eyeballs
    Blain's Farm & Fleet